Join our New York News e mail e-newsletter to get information, updates, and native insights delivered straight to your inbox!
The New York Metropolis Council ended 2024 passing ‘City of Yes’ that guarantees to construct greater than 80,000 new houses and assist alleviate the town’s housing disaster. However now, they’re instantly reversing course: a brand new Council invoice launched written particularly for the tech behemoth Airbnb is threatening to take tens-of-thousands of houses off the housing market and make life far much less reasonably priced for working folks.
The Council should reject this horrible invoice. As a lifelong tenant, I do know first-hand how thousands and thousands of on a regular basis New Yorkers like me are already affected by an affordability disaster that’s making it costlier than ever to lease a house. Taking much more houses away and incentivizing short-term leases over long-term tenants would solely make issues worse.
Proper now, the variety of rentable models throughout the town is at a traditionally low 1.4% — down from 4.5% simply three years in the past (whereas the speed of accessible lower-income houses is even decrease). And that scarcity is inflicting rents to skyrocket in all places. In simply the final 5 years, the median value of lease for studios, and 1- and 2-bedroom flats in New York Metropolis rose a ridiculous 16.3%. Right here in Brooklyn, which means you’d must make over $150,000 to comfortably afford the median lease value. The median family revenue is round half that quantity.
Each unit issues on this housing disaster and New Yorkers need assistance to climate this disaster however Airbnb’s invoice would go away them out within the chilly. Voters proceed to overwhelmingly cite the excessive value of dwelling as their high concern, and huge majorities of New Yorkers now say that each entry to reasonably priced housing and the price of dwelling have gotten worse within the final 12 months.
However corporations like Airbnb would solely deepen the disaster if allowed again into our neighborhoods. For years, these reserving service platforms made it simpler for landlords to illegally convert their houses from rentable models and switch them into mini-hotels that served vacationers as an alternative of tenants like me. In keeping with information from the town, at its peak, at the very least 43,000 unlawful models have been listed as short-term leases on Airbnb that might in any other case have been occupied by on a regular basis New Yorkers.
Fortunately, the Council took motion and handed Native Regulation 18 to rein in the issue and return our houses to the individuals who stay right here. That regulation, which went into impact final 12 months, strengthened enforcement towards short-term leases already in violation of current zoning and housing laws. And it gave the Metropolis the instruments it wanted to implement current state laws, penalizing the unhealthy landlords (which tenants know all too nicely) who overtly flouted the town’s legal guidelines.
However now, this new invoice would undo laws on all 1- and 2-family houses — which make up 29% of all our houses (and 14% of all rental models citywide) — and make them out there to transform again into Airbnbs. It might instantly take tens-of-thousands of flats again off the housing market and drive rents as much as new file highs. What’s worse: it could do away with necessities that house owners are current when somebody is staying of their house, making all New Yorkers (even householders!) susceptible to predatory personal fairness corporations making an attempt to purchase up our houses and switch them into mini-hotels.
And whereas small householders deserve assist to remain of their houses, too, we merely can’t afford to go laws that might exacerbate the housing disaster for all New Yorkers. Intro 1107 is designed to appear like a easy carve-out, but it surely’s actually Airbnb’s plan to decontrol your entire market and slide the rug out from underneath tenants preventing to maintain rents reasonably priced. As an alternative, renters want housing models preserved, and householders who’re struggling financially want mortgage help and different assist from the federal government.
As an alternative of taking part in into Airbnb’s scheme, our lawmakers should stand with the overwhelming majority of New Yorkers — tenants and renters — and prioritize laws that results in extra reasonably priced housing, not much less. And whereas there’s nonetheless a lot work to be finished to handle the housing and affordability crises affecting us all, rejecting laws like Intro 1107 is a straightforward means to make sure we don’t transfer backwards.
New York has already stood as much as the $85 billion greenback firm earlier than, and we will do it once more. The Metropolis Council ought to stand with New Yorkers in want and assure our houses stay out there to the individuals who stay and work right here – not tech and actual property traders making an attempt to get wealthy off our backs.
