New York Metropolis Corridor.
Photograph by Ethan Stark-Miller
In my tenure as an elected official, I’ve at all times believed in standing up for what’s proper, even when it might be tough or unpopular. It’s these guiding rules that led me to make the powerful resolution to depart the New York Metropolis Council’s Ladies’s Caucus. It definitely wasn’t a straightforward alternative, but it surely was a fully essential one.
The ultimate straw for me got here final week. All through this month, we’ve watched the televised launch of hostages and have since been haunted by the photographs of younger ladies of their early 20s being paraded by means of the streets by masked terrorists brandishing weapons of their faces. The pure terror within the eyes of these women was unmistakable. But regardless of what all of us witnessed as a focused assault on ladies, I used to be promptly denied after I requested the caucus to situation a press release of assist for the women. Even amid intentional acts of gender-based violence perpetrated by Hamas terrorists — together with the rape, torture, and kidnapping of so many ladies — the Caucus couldn’t bear to place out a press release with out including “context.”
If a bunch that claims to face for ladies’s rights can not converse out towards such horrific violence and terror, then what’s its function? The truth that the caucus opted for silence was not simply disappointing — it was alarming. The ladies who suffered by the hands of Hamas need to be acknowledged. Why is it that silence just isn’t “violence” in relation to advocating for Jewish ladies?
However it was not simply this situation that pushed me to depart; this occasion is simply a symptom of this caucus being held hostage by a rabid, excessive Leftist ideology. They’ve adopted insurance policies that undermine the very definition of womanhood, and have amended the bylaws to permit anybody who “identifies” as a lady to be a member. Keep in mind: these are individuals who, by and huge, select to ignore the distinctive challenges that organic ladies face — the identical individuals who declare males may give start and menstruate, and demand that “mothers” be known as birthing individuals. And those that don’t actively imagine this are intimidated into silence by those that do. Ladies have fought for generations to be acknowledged and guarded beneath the legislation. Now, those self same hard-won protections are being diluted by insurance policies that refuse to acknowledge organic actuality.
Let me be clear — I’m not stepping away from combating for ladies. The truth is, I’m doubling down on that combat and I can not in good conscience stay a part of a bunch that solely speaks up for ladies’s rights when it’s politically expedient for them.
Efficient advocacy requires consistency. We should defend ladies’s rights even when it doesn’t align with a most well-liked political agenda. Meaning we should condemn ALL types of violence and oppression towards ladies — whether or not these ladies are in New York Metropolis or in Israel. It means recognizing that girls face organic and societal challenges that require tailor-made insurance policies and protections.
Sadly, the Ladies’s Caucus not represents these rules. As a substitute of being a platform for the development of girls, it has develop into a platform for ideological activism that usually contradicts its core mission. I refuse to stay a part of a bunch that picks and chooses which ladies deserve
safety and advocacy. I’ll proceed to advocate for insurance policies that guarantee ladies’s security and dignity, and I’ll proceed to push for a political setting the place standing up for ladies just isn’t topic to partisan video games.
I hope my former colleagues within the Ladies’s Caucus take a step again and reassess what they really stand for. As a result of ladies — actual ladies — deserve higher.
