NYCHA Flats within the Rockaways.
By way of Google Maps
Join our QNS e mail publication to get information, updates, and native insights delivered straight to your inbox!
Eviction charges at New York Metropolis Housing Authority (NYCHA) properties underneath the Everlasting Affordability Dedication Collectively (PACT) program decreased barely in Queens in 2024, bucking a citywide pattern that noticed eviction charges spike considerably elsewhere in New York.
A current audit by NYC Comptroller Brad Lander discovered that eviction charges at PACT properties tripled in 2024 and resemble citywide eviction charges in personal properties.
The PACT program, designed to handle many years of underfunding and disrepair in public housing, transfers some administration duties to personal and non-profit companions to safe funding for vital renovations, aiming to handle an estimated $80 billion shortfall in NYCHA’s capital wants.
Nevertheless, the Comptroller’s current audit discovered that eviction filings and executions at PACT properties occurred at a sooner tempo than at different NYCHA developments all through the town and now resemble citywide eviction charges in personal rental models.
Evictions in PACT properties rose from 29 in 2023 to 91 in 2024—a staggering improve of over 300%. This introduced the eviction price at PACT properties to 0.57%, up from 0.18% final 12 months, almost matching the 0.60% price in personal rental models. In distinction, eviction charges at customary NYCHA properties elevated from 0.01% to 0.12% throughout the identical interval, rising from 15 to 180 evictions.
In Queens, nevertheless, the eviction price decreased barely in 2024 in comparison with 2023. NYCHA’s Ocean Bay Flats growth within the Rockaways, the one Queens-based NYCHA growth to transform to PACT, noticed evictions drop from 10 to eight in 2024, a drop of 20%.
Eviction charges spiked in all different boroughs containing PACT developments, leaping from seven evictions to 55 in Brooklyn, from 4 to 12 in Manhattan and from eight to 16 within the Bronx. A complete of 87 NYCHA developments have transformed to PACT, with none positioned in Staten Island.
Nevertheless, eviction filings at Ocean Bay Flats, which consists of 28 residential buildings, have been quickly growing lately, in response to the Comptroller’s audit.
The audit highlighted that there have been 33 filings in 2021, rising to 66 in 2022 and rising once more to 153 in 2023, a staggering 363% rise throughout the three-year interval. The Comptroller’s report included no knowledge for eviction filings in 2024. Elsewhere within the metropolis, filings rose at an excellent better tempo, leaping from 57 to 867 in Brooklyn throughout the identical interval in addition to leaping from 4 to 181 in Manhattan and from 38 to 313 within the Bronx.
The 153 eviction filings at Ocean Bay Flats represented roughly 10% of the 1,514 eviction filings registered in PACT properties throughout the town in 2024.
The audit, which was launched on Dec. 18, additionally criticized NYCHA for failing to make sure that PACT property managers adhered to pre-eviction outreach protocols and tenant protections. Auditors discovered that managers didn’t persistently make a number of makes an attempt to contact tenants liable to eviction, inform them of potential monetary help, or use on-site social service suppliers to have interaction with residents. Moreover, managers typically failed to determine compensation agreements or report all eviction-related actions, hindering NYCHA’s potential to supervise compliance.
Lander stated that NYCHA should do extra to make sure that PACT operators observe customary procedures and supply satisfactory help to tenants.
Nevertheless, the audit acknowledged some constructive steps taken by NYCHA, corresponding to growing resident involvement within the PACT course of. NYCHA representatives now meet with tenants to elucidate this system and focus on group wants earlier than renovations start.
In response, a NYCHA spokesperson defended this system, highlighting its success in investing $7 billion to redevelop and renovate public housing models since its inception.
“This unprecedented investment demonstrates our commitment to improving living conditions for NYCHA residents,” the spokesperson stated.
The spokesperson added that the Comptroller’s audit doesn’t take NYCHA’s monetary and operational challenges into consideration. The audit solely offers a “superficial assessment” of this system whereas making no substantive suggestions. Additionally they described PACT as “one of the most successful” long-term methods for preserving essential reasonably priced housing inventory.
The actual fact stays that there have been only a few evictions underneath PACT, and this system upholds resident rights and protections and offers households with ongoing social providers and monetary help to resolve current rental arrears. NYCHA and its PACT program undoubtedly prioritize conserving New Yorkers housed, and any suggestion in any other case is misguided and false.
NYCHA officers additionally advised QNS that the integrity of NYCHA buildings will proceed to say no with out the help of the PACT program. Officers famous that 24,000 properties have been transformed to this system so far, with repairs made to over 11,000 properties. NYCHA’s acknowledged objective is to transform 62,000 models to PACT by 2028.
Officers additionally contended that they made efforts all through the audit course of to supply the Comptroller’s group with extra info however stated the suggestions was not mirrored within the closing doc, stating that the authority is “concerned” by the shortage of context offered about resident rights and protections offered by the PACT packages. They famous that every one PACT websites are protected by each federal and native protections underneath this system.
NYCHA operates tons of of residential buildings in Queens throughout 21 completely different developments, together with 22 residential buildings in Astoria, 68 residential buildings in Jamaica, 51 residential buildings within the Rockaways, six in School Level, 125 in Flushing, 141 in Lengthy Island Metropolis and 55 in Woodside.
The authority at present has 177,569 residences in 2,411 buildings throughout the town in 335 standard public housing and PACT developments
