Join our Brooklyn Paper electronic mail publication to get information, updates, and native insights delivered straight to your inbox!
Mayor Eric Adams’ “City of Yes” housing plan took an enormous step ahead final week — with some important adjustments.
The plan is supposed to overtake previous zoning laws and make it simpler for every kind of housing to be constructed throughout New York Metropolis — growing housing inventory and hopefully easing the continuing housing disaster.
Outdated and new developments side-by-side in Williamsburg. Picture by Susan De Vries
On Nov. 21, after a day of contentious negotiations, which delayed votes in two Metropolis Council committees for hours, a deal was struck: the mayor agreed to regulate guidelines for parking minimums in some districts, restricted new “accessory dwelling units,” and pared again improvement districts in Queens and the Bronx.
‘City of Yes’ will get a sure
The adjusted Metropolis of Sure proposal handed the council’s Subcommittee on Zoning and Franchises 4-3, with “no” votes from council members representing less-dense neighborhoods on Staten Island and in jap Queens; and was permitted by the Committee on Land Use 8-2, with one abstention.
Only one Brooklyn consultant, Council Member Crystal Hudson — who voted in favor of Metropolis of Sure — sits on the Land Use committee, even though Brooklyn is the town’s most populous borough.
Undeterred by the adjustments, Adams celebrated the day as a victory.
Adams at a ‘City of Yes’ rally in April 2024. Picture courtesy of Michael Appleton/Mayoral Pictures Workplace
“Thanks to our shared commitment in building critically-needed housing, we have reached an agreement on a historic plan that could open the doors to a little more housing in every neighborhood in our city — with no borough, block, or backyard left behind,” he stated in a press release. “If passed, New York City will, once again, serve as a model to the nation on government’s infinite ability to take challenges head-on, set forth a bold agenda, and get the job done. To my partners in the City Council, let’s say ‘yes’ to City of Yes.”
Now headed to the Metropolis Planning Fee earlier than a remaining vote by the complete Metropolis Council on Dec. 5, the proposal is anticipated to create 80,000 new housing models – lower than the 150,000 the unique plan would have created.
The complete affect the amended plan can have on Brooklyn is unclear, however critics stated it represents a uncooked deal for the borough.
In a press release, Brooklyn Borough President Antonio Reynoso stated the amended proposal doesn’t do sufficient to upzone low-density neighborhoods, that are usually wealthier and stuffed with single-family houses.
In consequence, he stated, these nabes will stay “exclusive” and segregated and strain will enhance in different areas — together with higher-density neighborhoods in Brooklyn.
“City of Yes was never going to fix everything. It was never an affordability strategy, it was never a production plan, and it was never a panacea for our city’s housing crisis,” Reynoso stated. “But it was at least a modest opportunity to begin addressing the discriminatory zoning practices that force low-income, Black and Brown neighborhoods to do all of the work of building new housing while low-density neighborhoods get away with contributing nothing.”
Kelly Carroll, the chief director of the Atlantic Avenue Enterprise Enchancment District, stated Metropolis of Sure for Housing Alternative was unlikely to vary a lot across the Atlantic Avenue hall in Downtown Brooklyn and Boerum Hill, since a lot of the realm consists of historic districts.
Throughout the board, Carroll, who can also be a board member on the Historic Districts Council and Metropolis Membership of New York, and an adjunct professor at NYU, stated Metropolis of Sure for Housing Alternative didn’t go far sufficient in addressing the town’s affordability disaster. She stated inexpensive models in new developments ought to be mandated, not optionally available.
Homes within the Boerum Hill historic district, one among many who might be largely unaffected by Metropolis of Sure. File photograph by Susan De Vries
“If you’re going to be saying affordable housing is a goal, allowing private developers to opt in as a choice falls terribly short, it should be mandatory,” she stated.
Metropolis of Sure for Housing Alternative features a “Universal Affordability Preference” clause, which might permit builders to construct extra housing if the extra models have been made “affordable” to a sure level. The council set that affordability threshold to 60% of the Space Median Revenue, or $83,880 yearly for a household of three, which can make opting in even much less fascinating for builders, Carroll stated.
“Supply and demand only works in a free market and New York City is not a free market,” she stated. “We have many types of regulated housing in the mix, such as Mitchell Lama, such as NYCHA, such as rent control, rent stabilization, and so just adding supply doesn’t work in this formula.”
In Brooklyn, median rental costs have risen 3.2% year-over-year, in response to a current Douglas-Elliman report, with median lease hovering round $4,000 per thirty days. Two-bedroom residences have been leasing for a median of $4,212 — a charge thought-about “affordable” for a household of three incomes roughly 130% AMI, or $181,740 yearly.
Some see alternative, regardless of setbacks
Fifth Avenue Committee government director Michelle de la Uz stated the group was totally supportive of the zoning reform, and specifically stated the Common Affordability Choice, lifting parking mandates, and enabling the creation of accent dwelling models in some areas “will ensure that communities throughout the city are able to contribute to solving our housing crisis.”
“Importantly, the City Council has secured a commitment of $5 billion from the city and the state to invest in infrastructure and affordable housing as part of implementing the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity,” she added. “Our housing crisis can be solved with a combination of political will and significant investment, and these are critical steps forward toward that goal.”
Some Brooklynites say Metropolis of Sure represents progress, regardless of its adjustments. Picture courtesy of Kidfly182/Wikimedia Commons
In the meantime, Ofer Cohen, co-founder of latest Brooklyn-based housing improvement firm Ailanthus stated Metropolis of Sure was “the most comprehensive citywide zoning reform in over 50 years, even despite the last-minute compromises, City of Yes is a critical step toward addressing New York City’s housing crisis, which has had a profound impact on Brooklyn and the entire city.”
Ofer, who was previously the board chair of the Downtown Brooklyn Partnership and is on the board of the Brooklyn Navy Yard and the Brooklyn Chamber of Commerce, launched Ailanthus earlier this yr in partnership with Tucker Reed and Vivian Liao, who’re additionally behind Brooklyn improvement agency Totem.
Cohen stated Ailanthus, supported by Metropolis of Sure reforms, desires to extend New Yorkers’ entry to inexpensive housing by creating 10,000 housing models over the subsequent 5 years.
“We are deeply encouraged by the City Council’s approval of this forward-thinking initiative, which sets clear guidelines to create a more equitable future for all,” he stated.
